Birkenstock Madrid Sandal Review Updated 2025: Big Buckle, EVA, and the Magic of the Original One-Strap Classic

The Magic of the Madrid

I have one pair of Birkenstock Madrid sandals in Brown Magic Galaxy with an original footbed.  They go with just about everything and are really comfortable.  I love these Madrids and yet, I rarely wear them.

The Birkenstock Madrid is one of the brand’s most iconic one-strap sandals — minimalist, versatile, and still handmade in Germany.  For those of you unfamiliar with the Madrid model, it is a single strap Birkenstock.  The strap covers only the top portion of your foot. 

 Birkenstock Madrid Magic Galaxy Sandal — Single Strap Design

The classic Birkenstock Madrid in shimmering Brown Magic Galaxy — simple, chic, and timeless.

The Origins of the Birkenstock Madrid

The Madrid was the first Birkenstock sandal ever made.  According to the Birkenstock Group, “in 1963 Karl Birkenstock launches the Madrid model, the first fitness sandal with a deep and flexible footbed, thereby laying the foundation for today's comfort footwear market”.

For anyone wondering where Birkenstocks are made, yes — the Birkenstock Madrid is made in Germany, using premium materials and cork-latex footbeds that have barely changed since the 1960s.

A Simple, Stylish, and Surprisingly Supportive Design

I have always admired the Birkenstock Madrid.  It is a classic slide sandal.  I have noticed more women wearing the Madrid over the last few years.   This model of Birkenstock has a fantastic range of style.  The Madrid can be worn for dressy occasions or worn causally like a flip flop.  Whether you choose a classic leather upper or a modern synthetic finish, Birkenstock Madrid sandals offer that signature arch support and deep heel cup that sets them apart from dupes and imitators.

The Magic Galaxy Madrid: A Hard-to-Find Gem

When the Magic Galaxy uppers were unveiled a few months ago, I knew I had to add it to my collection.  Finding this shoe in my size and width was as difficult as pulling a rabbit out of a hat.  Why?  This particular Madrid was only being offered in narrow width in the US.  The only Madrid I could find in a regular width, on this continent, was in black.  While black might be a good neutral color for some people, I associate neutral color Birkenstocks with the 1990s.  Back in the day, Birkenstocks were only sold in brown, black, or grey.  If I am going to spend my hard earned money on a luxury item, it has to be unique.

The Original Birkenstock Madrid — A One-Strap Icon Since 1963

Finding a regular-width Madrid in Magic Galaxy felt like pulling a rabbit out of a hat — but so worth it.

Sleek Look, Perfect Fit — Even for Wide Feet

I did not want to be excluded from owning an elegant pair of Madrids in Magic Galaxy because of my wide feet.  I went to great lengths to acquire this specific shoe in my size and I ordered it internationally.  It seems that the US marketplace is not catering to women with normal to wider feet, compared to Europe, where Birkenstocks can easily be located in all widths.

Upon arrival, I was concerned that the regular width Madrid might still be too narrow.  Out of the box, it appeared much sleeker compared to other models, like the Gizeh or the Arizona.  However, when I slipped my foot into the Madrid, the footbed felt perfect.  To compare, I put a Madrid on one foot and a Gizeh on the other.  The footbeds felt the same.  I was delighted.  The one-strap sandal created an illusion of being more narrow.  I am no fashion expert, but I assume this is because there was less material versus two or three strap model Birkenstocks.  For a woman with a wide width foot, this was a welcomed illusion.

The One-Strap Illusion: Comfort That Defies Expectations

Before ever trying a Madrid, I had an assumption that it would be hard to keep on my foot because of the single strap.  Sometimes assumptions are good, and other times they can cloud our judgment.  In the case of the Madrid, my assumption was 100% wrong because my foot stayed put on the footbed while I walked.  I still don’t know how a single adjustable strap can keep a shoe on one’s foot so securely.  It must be the particular way that the strap is shaped and placed around the foot.  It’s like magic.

From Summer Sandal to Everyday Slide

For some odd reason, I felt like I could only wear the Madirds on warm days.  Why?  Maybe because so much of my foot is exposed with only a single strap.  Perhaps the reason why I was not wearing these shoes so frequently was due to the fact that warm days in the Bay Area are a rare occurrence.  When the temperature warmed up the other afternoon, I rolled up my jeans and slipped on the Madrids.  I wore them around the house doing my dreaded Monday chores.  Wearing these cute, sparkly shoes while cleaning the house made my chores much more tolerable.

Style Inspiration: How to Wear the Madrid

That same day, when it was time to pick up the kids from summer camp, the fog started to blow in.  I rolled down my jeans and thought about putting on a different pair of Birkenstocks.  Instead, I slipped my feet back into the Madrids.  It was at that very moment when I realized that they could be worn with jeans too!  My assumption that Madrids could only be worn on warm days vanished as quickly as David Copperfield made the Statue of Liberty disappear. 

Perfect Fit, Sleek Look

The one-strap Madrid may look narrow, but it fits like a dream — even for wider feet.

Proof that Madrids work with more than summer outfits — they look amazing with rolled-up jeans, too.

This insight was spellbinding.  My mind raced with ideas of various outfits that I could pair with the Madrids.  It’s like a magician holding a deck of 52 cards out to an audience member.  Which card would the audience member choose?  Which outfit would I pair with the Madrids?  I was filled with excitement as I had so many choices.  No longer were my Madrids only shoes that I could wear on a hot day, I could also wear them on cool days.  Jeans and Madrids looked awesome together.

I liked that the Madrids were supportive and comfortable while I walked around town.    Even though Birkenstock marketed the Madrid in the 1960s as a fitness sandal, I probably would not chose the Madrids for walking long distances.  Only because it takes more effort for my toes to grip the shoe without a second strap for added support.

---

Flip-Flop Sound, Full Birkenstock Support

One unique thing about the Madrids is the sound they make while you walk.  You get the “flip flop” sound like you might hear when walking in beach-type thongs.  Other two and three strap Birkenstock models do not make a “flip flop” noise as you walk.  ​

Birkenstock Madrid EVA Review: Lightweight, Waterproof & Travel-Ready

The Magic Galaxy Madrids proved that even one strap can offer amazing support.  But what happens when you swap cork and leather for foam and water resistance?   Enter the EVA Madrid — the flashy, travel-ready cousin that trades structure for splashability.

While the Madrid EVA looks fun and travel-friendly, it’s not a shoe I’d rely on for comfort or durability. In my blog Traveling with Birkenstocks, I explained how the EVA version came only in narrow width — a frustrating limitation for those of us with regular or wider feet. The material itself is flexible and waterproof, which makes it great for poolside lounging, but not for long walks or all-day wear. I found them slippery when wet and noticeably less supportive than the classic cork-footbed Madrid.

Birkenstock Madrid EVA in Red — Immediately Returned in 2016

I returned these red Madrid EVA sandals the same day I bought them. They lacked everything I loved about my supportive Magic Galaxy Madrids — no structure, slippery when walking, and I honestly felt like I might twist my ankle.

That said, Birkenstock surprised fans by releasing a Water-Friendly Madrid Big Buckle EVA — finally giving the minimalist slide a touch of glamour and practicality. The oversized buckle adds personality, and the design feels a bit more elevated than the basic EVA models. Still, even with the upgrade, the EVA Madrid remains best suited for short wear, beach days, or travel backup shoes—not a full replacement for your cork classics.

​The Birkenstock Madrid EVA and newer Big Buckle EVA sandals are popular for beach or spa wear, but they’re not as supportive as the cork-footbed models.

Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle Review: 2018 Release, Fit, Comfort, and Collector Appeal

When Birkenstock released the Big Buckle Madrid in 2018, I jumped on the bandwagon faster than you can say “limited edition.” I tracked down both the black and cognac pairs from a European retailer on eBay — one of the few places offering them in regular width. 

I especially loved my Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle Oiled Leather pair — the black finish looked so chic and felt a bit sturdier than my earlier Madrids.

Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle in Black Oiled Leather — 2018 Release

My black oiled leather Big Buckle Madrids — one of the first pairs I tracked down in 2018. I loved the elevated look and extra support from the wider strap, but that chunky buckle? Cute in photos, not so comfy in real life. These eventually found a new home after spending more time in my closet than on my feet.

Eventually, I scored the Big Buckle Madrid in Zinfandel with rose gold buckles, which felt like a total collector’s dream. I absolutely loved the elevated look — that oversized buckle gave the classic one-strap sandal a dose of luxury, and the wider strap offered noticeably more support than the original Madrid. 

Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle Review: Watch the Oiled Leather Pair in Motion

But as much as I admired the design, I struggled with the buckle itself.  Stylish? Absolutely.  Comfortable?  Not so much.  The big metal hardware hit right on the top of my foot, making it painful to wear for long. I eventually sold off the black and cognac pairs since they were collecting dust, but I still hold on to my Zinfandel Big Buckle Madrids — they’re too stunning (and too rare) to let go. I save them for special days when comfort can take a backseat to style.

Final Thoughts: Why the Madrid Deserves a Spot in Every Collection

Whether you prefer the classic cork style, the water friendly EVA Madrid, or the modern Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle version, this silhouette remains one of Birkenstock’s most affordable and stylish entry points.

The Madrids are less expensive compared to other Birkenstock models, they are available in a multitude of colors, and the uppers can be found in leather or synthetic materials.  I have only seen this model sold in the Original Footbed.  I am curious if any of my readers have come across this shoe in a soft footbed.  

With a rainbow of colors from which to choose, I will most definitely be purchasing another pair of colorful Birkenstock Madrids in the future.  Even though I won’t be wearing these for walking long distances, I will wear them just about any other time.  Don’t let the flip flop style of this shoe deceive you.  Even with just one strap, the Madrids provide just as much arch support as other Birkenstocks and they magically stay on your feet as you walk. 

I Love Birkenstocks and I Love the Birkenstock Madrid.

---

Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle in Zinfandel Oiled Leather with Rose Gold Buckles and Socks

Yes, you can wear Madrids with socks — especially when they’re this good. My Zinfandel oiled leather Big Buckle Madrids with rose gold hardware prove that cozy and chic can totally coexist.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Birkenstock Madrid

Are Birkenstock Madrid sandals comfortable for walking?
Birkenstock Madrid sandals are comfortable for short walks, errands, and everyday wear — but they’re not ideal for long-distance walking. Because they only have one strap, your toes do a little extra work to keep the sandal in place. That said, the cork footbed still provides the same legendary arch and heel support as other Birkenstock models.

Do Birkenstock Madrids come in regular and narrow widths?
Yes, the Madrid is made in both regular and narrow widths — but availability depends on region and retailer. In the U.S., many styles (especially limited editions) are offered only in narrow width, while European shops often stock both.  With the current state of affairs in 2025 (tariffs), I can no longer recommend that if you have a regular or wider foot to consider ordering from a European retailer or eBay listing that specifies “regular width".

Are Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle sandals worth it?
The Big Buckle Madrid adds instant style and extra support thanks to a thicker strap and statement buckle. However, comfort varies. I found the larger buckle hits right at the top of my foot — stylish but not always comfortable for all-day wear. If you want a dressier Birkenstock that still has that signature cork support, the Big Buckle Madrid is a fun, collector-worthy option.

Are Birkenstock Madrids true to size?
Yes — Birkenstock Madrids run true to size, but the single strap can make them feel slightly looser compared to multi-strap models like the Arizona. If you’re between sizes, start with your normal Birkenstock size and adjust the buckle for the best fit.

Are Birkenstock Madrids made in Germany?
Absolutely. Authentic Birkenstock Madrids are made in Germany, just like the rest of the brand’s cork-footbed collection. Each pair is crafted using sustainable materials, including natural cork, jute, and suede-lined footbeds — proof that “Made in Germany” still means quality craftsmanship.

How do I style Birkenstock Madrid sandals?
Keep it simple — Madrids pair beautifully with rolled-up jeans, linen pants, flowy skirts, or even swimsuits.  I love wearing my Magic Galaxy Madrids with denim for an easy, polished look. Their sleek one-strap design makes them one of the most versatile Birkenstocks ever made.

How do I clean my Birkenstock Madrids?
Use a soft brush or damp cloth to remove dust and dirt. For cork maintenance, apply Birkenstock Cork Sealer or Kelly’s Cork Renew to keep the edges from drying out. For synthetic or EVA versions, a little mild soap and warm water works wonders.  Avoid soaking — that’s the quickest way to ruin a good pair of Birks!

---

Related Reads: Birkenstock Sizing, Style, Care, and Collector Guides from I Love Birkenstocks

If you’re new to Birkenstocks or figuring out your fit, start with Stepping Into Your First Pair — my go-to guide for sizing, widths, and understanding those little foot icons stamped into the footbed.

Wondering if men can wear Madrids? You’ll love Birkenstock & Men — proof that Birks look great on everyone, from Bay Area dads to Hollywood icons.

Curious about socks with sandals? My post Socks & Stocks settles the debate once and for all — comfort and confidence win every time.

For a look at who wears Birkenstocks at every age, read Young & Old Love to Wear Birkenstocks — it’s one of my favorite feel-good stories about generations united by cork and comfort.

If the Madrid isn’t your perfect match, Birkenstock Styles compares all the classic silhouettes — from Arizonas to Bostons — to help you find “the one.”

Shopping secondhand? Protect yourself with my Spotting Fake Birkenstocks three part series where you learn how to identify counterfeit Birkenstocks.  

And because Madrids have a lot of exposed cork, learn how to keep that edge sealed and strong in Birkenstock Cork Sealer vs. Kelly’s Cork Renew — your guide to keeping footbeds glossy, smooth, and crack-free.

---

Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle in Alsa Green with Gold Buckles Styled with Levi Jeans | ​Follow me on Instagram @ilovebirkenstocks for more Birkenstock styles, tips, and honest reviews straight from my collection.

Fresh, modern, and a little bit glam — my Alsa Green Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle sandals with gold hardware pair perfectly with cuffed jeans.

Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle “Lion King” Limited Edition from Bloomingdale’s 2019 Pop-Up |  Come hang out on my Facebook page for more rare Birkenstock shots and behind-the-scenes sneak peeks!

In 2019, Bloomingdale’s hosted a Disney-themed pop-up called The Carousel to celebrate the live-action Lion King remake — and these gold Big Buckle Birkenstock Madrids fit right in. Though not an official Birkenstock x Disney collaboration, this limited-edition colorway captured the regal vibe perfectly.

---